Explore all skills
Plumbing Beginner

Replace a Running Toilet Flapper

Diagnose a worn toilet flapper, select a compatible replacement, adjust the lift chain, and confirm that the tank refills without leaking into the bowl.
30 minutes 7 steps 4 safety notes
AS

Guided byAarav SandhuResidential plumbing technician and maintenance trainer

Replace a Running Toilet Flapper Published learning guide

Safety first

  • Close the toilet shut-off valve before placing hands inside the tank.
  • Do not use in-tank chemical tablets while working because residue can irritate skin and damage seals.
  • Do not force a corroded shut-off valve or brittle flush-valve component.
  • Stop and contact a plumber if the tank is cracked, the isolation valve leaks, or water appears around the toilet base.

Follow each step in order

Your progress stays on this device.
  1. 01

    Confirm the source of the running water

    Remove the tank lid carefully and place it on a padded surface. Observe whether water is leaking past the flapper into the bowl rather than overflowing through the refill tube.
  2. 02

    Shut off and drain the tank

    Close the fixture shut-off valve clockwise without forcing it. Flush once and hold the handle to drain most of the tank, then absorb the remaining water near the flapper.
  3. 03

    Document the existing setup

    Photograph the flapper, chain attachment, and flush valve. Note the toilet brand or model and measure the flush-valve opening when compatibility is unclear.
  4. 04

    Remove the old flapper

    Disconnect the lift chain from the flush lever, then release the flapper ears or mounting ring from the overflow tube without bending brittle plastic parts.
  5. 05

    Clean and inspect the sealing surface

    Wipe the flush-valve seat with a clean cloth. Stop if it is cracked, deeply pitted, loose, or covered by damage that a replacement flapper cannot seal.
  6. 06

    Install and adjust the replacement

    Attach the compatible flapper evenly and reconnect the chain with slight slack. Ensure the chain cannot catch under the flapper or prevent it from opening fully.
  7. 07

    Restore water and test several flushes

    Open the shut-off valve slowly, allow the tank to fill, and flush three times. Confirm the flapper closes consistently, the fill stops at the correct level, and no connection leaks.